Geno Smith or J.J. McCarthy: Redraft Trade Value
Who ranks higher for the rest of this season, Geno Smith or J.J. McCarthy?
Geno Smith ranks QB22 and #171 overall for the rest of the season on the consensus board. By source: Sleeper QB19, ESPN QB25, Yahoo QB22. Sleeper is highest on Geno Smith and ESPN is lowest.
J.J. McCarthy ranks QB21 and #169 overall for the rest of the season on the consensus board. By source: Sleeper QB20, ESPN QB17, Yahoo QB23. ESPN is highest on J.J. McCarthy and Yahoo is lowest.
Who has the easier schedule the rest of the way, Geno Smith or J.J. McCarthy?
For Geno Smith (NYJ), the remaining schedule (Weeks 11 to 18) is the 11th toughest of 32 for quarterbacks.
Next up for Geno Smith: at LAC (Week 11), at MIA (Week 12), vs DEN (Week 14).
For J.J. McCarthy (NYG), the remaining schedule (Weeks 11 to 18) is the 13th easiest of 32 for quarterbacks.
Next up for J.J. McCarthy: vs JAX (Week 11), at IND (Week 12), vs SF (Week 13).
See every team on the strength of schedule page.
Who has more redraft trade value, Geno Smith or J.J. McCarthy?
Geno Smith (QB, NYJ) has a redraft trade value of 1,140.
J.J. McCarthy (QB, NYG) has a redraft trade value of 1,173.
Both values use the site baseline of 12 teams, 1QB and PPR scoring; the calculator adjusts them to any league’s settings.
One for one, Geno Smith for J.J. McCarthy is an even trade in the redraft trade calculator: each side holds between 47% and 53% of the value.
Open this trade in the calculator.
Open in the trade calculator · Geno Smith profile · J.J. McCarthy profile
More comparisons: Geno Smith or Deshaun Watson · Geno Smith or Matthew Stafford · Geno Smith or Joe Milton · J.J. McCarthy or Baker Mayfield · J.J. McCarthy or Deshaun Watson · J.J. McCarthy or Matthew Stafford